Last week, we reported on the decision by community leaders in Chumbivilcas, Cuzco, to suspend a threatened strike in protest against Las Bambas, the Chinese owned copper mine in neighbouring Apurímac region. This ran in parallel to judicial moves that reversed earlier verdicts clearing community leaders from prosecution.
In late July, a Court in Arequipa resolved to overturn the appeal which had absolved 19 community leaders and human rights defenders of the original sentence received by them for their involvement in a series of social protests against Las Bambas dating back to September 2015. With this decision, the Court has thus reopened criminal proceedings against these leaders who had hoped that the earlier judicial decision of October 2020 was final and conclusive.
According to the Federación Ecuménica para la Paz, Fedepaz, this decision is arbitrary and violates the right to due process of the 19 defenders. The decision was based on the argument that the October sentence had failed to consider all the evidence and that the prosecutor had not identified specific charges against each of the defenders.
For Fedepaz, this decision lacks legal basis since the previous judge had indeed analysed all the evidence and, also importantly, the prosecutor’s office cannot request for the proceedings to be re-opened on the argument that the prosecutor in charge had made mistakes during the earlier proceedings.
In essence this would simply pass on responsibility of such alleged mistakes to those accused but absolved. In Fedepaz’s opinion, this would be completely arbitrary.
Recent Comments