CEPKA, the indigenous organisation representing 43 Kichwa communities of the San Martín region held a virtual press conference on 1 July, accusing the Ministry of Environment (Minam), The Ministry of Agriculture and the National Service of Protected Areas of infringing the right of the Puerto Franco community to a land title. They also denounced the failure to protect and title the collective territories of Indigenous peoples, thereby putting their lands and livelihoods at risk.
The Kichwa communities had the support of the Instituto de Defensa Legal (IDL) and, internationally, that of the Forest People’s Programme (FPP) whose communiqué provides helpful background to this case.
FPP argues that the creation of the Cordillera Azul National Park in 2001 was not accompanied, as legally required, by a process of free, prior and informed consent (FPIC) and to date the great majority of Kichwa territories remain untitled. In 2005, the Cordillera Escalera National Park was also established on a similar basis; no participatory work was involved, nor was the required process followed of obtaining the FPIC of the local communities.
In July 2020, Minam announced a proposal to modify the Law of National Protected Areas (NPA) and Regional Conservation Areas. This states that the executor of a management contract of an NPA must be a private legal entity, either profit or non-profit making. However, as FPP points out, states are already obliged to engage with indigenous peoples as allies in conservation.
A report of the former UN Special Rapporteur of the Human Rights Council questions “models of conservation that not only ignore indigenous peoples’ rights, but also make them invisible and expel them from their territories, denying their contribution to forest conservation”. Such exclusion persists each time the master plans for the national parks are updated (as they were in 2017 and 2018) without reference to the Kichwa’s land rights.
The Cordillera Azul National Park has been managed since 2002 by the Centre for Conservation, Research and Management of Natural Areas (CIMA), an NGO. According to FPP, CIMA made an arrangement in 2014 with an investment firm in Luxembourg for the sale of 8 million carbon credits that generated 8.5 million euros. Since 2018, the park has been included in the Green List of the International Union of Conservation for Nature (IUCN), which implies effective participation by indigenous communities in its management, as well as distribution of benefits to the communities.
For the FPP and other supporters of the Kichwa, “Puerto Franco offers a clear example of how indigenous rights are being pushed to one side as the community’s lands remain untitled. The community has suffered the imposition of the National Park. The Kichwa’s territories now generate credits for the international carbon market, without any tangible benefits for the indigenous population”.
In this case, IDL affirms, Peru is at odds with accepted international practise of conservation with the participation of indigenous communities. Not only do the Kichwa confront national parks but also the forestry service (Serfor) which issues logging concessions within Kichwa territory. Without title to their territory the Kichwa are also vulnerable to invasion by settlers.
Recent Comments