On 12 January, the UN High Commission of Human Rights (UNHCHR) published its findings following a visit to Peru on 17-20 November to investigate allegations of human rights violations against protesters during the mass protests that took place in Lima on 9-15 November. It concluded that police used unnecessary and excessive force to handle protests, violating international human rights norms and standards. The actions of the police resulted in two deaths and more than 200 people injured.
The report found that the police contravened the international principles of legality, necessity, proportionality, precaution and non-discrimination. It noted that the police failed to distinguish between those conducting themselves peacefully and a minority that acted in a violent manner. It highlighted evidence showing that plain clothes police conducted a series of arbitrary detentions without stating their reasons for doing so. The Commission identified violations to due process, cases of ill treatment (some amounting to torture), harassment and sexual abuse during detention.
UNHCR expressed concern over legislation that guarantees police immunity from prosecution when carrying out policing functions, as well as the use of lethal weapons. The Law for Police Protection, passed in March 2020, not only exempts police from prosecution but prevents prosecutors investigating police officers from ordering preventive detention. The law also eliminated the principle of proportionality in the use of force, contravening international norms and principles.
The report highlighted other human rights violations that took place during and following the November protests. These included violations to freedom of expression and the right to defend human rights. There were 40 attacks documented against journalists, including examples of three journalists injured by pellet shots. There were also reports of abuse against staff from the Ombudsman’s Office (Defensoría), including police threats and insults. The Commission cited the case of the detention of human rights defender Carlos Rodríguez, a lawyer from the Coordinadora Nacional de Derechos Humanos, who was held in detention for 15 hours after going to a police station to monitor the situation of people detained.
UNHCR said it welcomes efforts by the Sagasti government to investigate the November events, citing the Multisectoral Commission set up to oversee investigations into human rights violations, as well as reparations to victims and their families. It made a series of recommendations to the government including:
- Ensuring the necessary conditions to guarantee that freedom of expression, freedom of the press and the right to protest are upheld.
- Ending all penal investigations and administrative processes against people arbitrarily detained because of their participation in the protests.
- Derogation of the Law for Police Protection and guarantees on the principle of proportionality in the use of force, with police officers no longer exempted from prosecution when causing injuries or death.
- Guarantees of prompt, independent, impartial and exhaustive investigations into all the human rights violations committed during the protests.
- Strengthening police awareness, as well as that of prosecutors, judges and public defenders of the international standards for the use of force, arbitrary detentions, sexual violence, torture and ill-treatment, protest, etc.
- Guarantees that all detainees have access to a lawyer and communication with their families. Police should also have full and updated lists of those being held in detention.
- Ending the use of plain clothes police to make arrests.
- Guarantees that human rights defenders, journalists, and Defensoría officials are protected and can carry out their work without hindrance or reprisals.
- Granting of reparations to victims and their families.
- Preventing human rights violations in response to protests.
Recent Comments