On 6 January, the Constitutional Tribunal (TC) published its decision on the legality of the use of ‘preventive states of emergency’. This prohibits the government from declaring states of emergency when it is clear that all the requirements needed to justify a restriction on civil liberties have not been met. Until very recently, ‘preventive’ states of emergency were often used, restricting the right to protest and helping to criminalise those who engage in it.

The TC granted the petition for habeas corpus submitted against the Council of Ministers in October 2017 by local community organisations from Cotabambas province in Apurímac region. These included the Frente Único de Defensa de Chalhuahuacho, the Federación Campesina de Mujeres de Chalhuahuacho, and the Federación de Jóvenes Paki Waraka. The communities’ case was supported by the Instituto de Defensa Legal, Aprodeh and the Coordinadora Nacional de Derechos Humanos

The case followed continuous use of states of emergency in and around the Las Bambas to pre-empt possible social conflicts. Civil liberties were restricted although there was no evidence of the need for an increased police presence.

The Instituto de Defensa Legal stresses the innovative nature of the tribunal’s decision. It says it deals with the issue in hand, despite the fact that the violation of rights, as outlined in the demand, has now ceased. The TC expresses the hope that the reasons that led to the demand are not repeated. In its sentence, it states that “it should be ensured (se debe disponer) that the executive does not resort to the actions that led to the submission of this demand”.

The TC affirms that use of states of emergency must be subject to three principles being satisfied:

  • The principle of temporality. A state of emergency must have a time limit designed to facilitate the resolution of the problems that led to it in the first place.
  • The principle of proportionality. It needs to be proportionate to the issue that it seeks to resolve.
  • The principle of necessity. This means that there is no other way to resolve the emergency. Priority must first be given to negotiation and to permanent dialogue, with a state of exception only used when all other means have proved unsuccessful.

By establishing clear limits to the use of states of emergencies, it is hoped that the Executive will think twice before using it and that it ceases to be used as a tool to ‘neutralise’ legitimate protest. As the Instituto de Defensa Legal says, this ruling “needs to change one of the most rooted state practices, including [those of] the National Police, practices that have been so counterproductive in their dealings with social conflict”.

To see the Tribunal’s decision, see here.