The proposed Hidrovía Project, which would involve extensive dredging to improve navigation along the Huallaga, Ucayali, Marañon and Amazon rivers, has been heavily criticised because of the likely impacts on the rivers themselves, the fauna and flora, and the populations living along them. The impacts of interventions along the Mekong in south-east Asia provide valuable lessons in what not to do.

The Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) for the Hidrovía was twice rejected by SENACE, the government authority responsible for approving such assessments. The Mekong experience suggests that the wisest decision might be to abandon the project altogether.

The Hidrovía formed part of a programme sponsored by the Brazilian government to integrate South America through a series of large-scale infrastructure projects. With a view to pushing ahead with it, the Peruvian government granted a concession in 2017 to Cohidro, a consortium led by the Chinese Synohidro Corporation. This sought to improve navigation along the four rivers as part of a larger proposal to develop a multimodal transport network between the western and eastern coasts of South America.

To implement the contract signed with the government, Cohidro developed an EIA which has been widely criticised.

Perhaps the best-informed critic has been Jorge Abad, executive director of the Water Research and Technology Centre (CITA) of the Engineering and Technology University (UTEC), who argues that the Ministry of Transport and Communications needs to seek expert advice to improve the technical standards incorporated in the terms of reference for such contracts.

The problems encountered with the two versions of the EIA rejected by SENACE include, among others:

  • The absence of an integrated approach to the four interconnected rivers.
  • The lack of proposals to measure the transport of sediment in view of the dredging of the rivers.
  • The contract specified the dredging of 13 critical points along the rivers. The detailed engineering study identified 23, showing the ministry’s lack familiarity with the rivers when it signed the contract.
  • The weakness of the terms of reference developed by the ministry. These do not take into account information produced by the Bureau of Meteorology (SENAMHI), the National Water Authority (ANA) and the Navy.
  • Given the lack of data and information in general about the rivers, the EIA should have been developed after the completion of the detailed engineering study. This would have enabled information generated in the study to be incorporated in the EIA, helping it make more accurate predictions about possible impacts.
  • Neither the terms of reference nor the subsequent studies have taken into account the fact that the rivers are habitats for flora and fauna and that large-scale interventions could have important impacts on the natural biodiversity.
  • The EIA does not take adequate account of the impacts of dredging and subsequent fluvial traffic on fishing, the principal source of livelihood for those living along the rivers.
  • The studies for dredging were made during the high-water season and did not take into account impacts during the low-water season, an important factor given the difference in water levels and flows.
  • The EIA did not take into account the possible impacts on the Pacaya Samiria RAMSAR site, one of the areas of highest biodiversity on the planet.

In addition to these concerns inherent to the project itself are the lessons to be learned from the experience with the Mekong river in south-east Asia. The Mekong flows for 4,880 km from north to south from China through Myanmar, Laos, Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam before it enters the South China Sea. It is the world’s eighth largest river and its fish resources – the largest continental production in the world – sustain the livelihoods of 60 million persons.

As a result of dredging to promote the transport of Chinese exports along the river to nearby countries, plus the construction of large-scale hydroelectric dams in southern China and Laos, the fishermen and women, the farmers and the people that live along the banks suffered the consequences of a reduction in river water levels and fish catches.

Scientists and conservationists warned of the likely consequences of these massive interventions in the river and its tributaries, but their warnings were ignored. In 2010 the Mekong River Commission, a multigovernmental commission charged with producing studies of the river and providing policy advice to the regional governments, warned that, although the proposed dams would produce more electricity, they would drastically alter the water flows along the river and affect fishing, agriculture and biodiversity (including the extinction of the Mekong river catfish and the Irrawaddy river dolphin).

In July 2018, one of the dams under construction in Laos collapsed, flooding several villages and causing 26 deaths. More than 100 people disappeared and over 6,000 people were displaced. At the end of the decade, Brian Eyler, director of the South East Asia Programme of the Stimson Centre in Washington DC, warned that the Mekong river was approaching the tipping point after which the dramatic changes developed would be irreversible.

The experience to date with the Hidrovía project repeats the story of weak terms of reference, lack of information, and inadequate and limited impact studies. Scientists and others are warning of the unforeseeable and possibly dramatic consequences of the proposed interventions in the rivers. However, in this case, there is still time to heed the warnings and to cancel the project.