The Ombudsman’s office (Defensoría del Pueblo) has produced an important report, published earlier this month, fulfilling its oversight role in managing the environment. In 149 carefully documented pages, the report details who is responsible for monitoring the management of ‘environmental liabilities’ left behind by mining and hydrocarbons activity, and reports on how well the task is being done.

A ‘liability’ is taken to mean a situation left after an activity has stopped that impacts on public health by means of water, air, soil, flora and fauna. Among a multiplicity of causes, such risks may arise from deforestation or the inadequate disposal of mining residues.

The report finds that the Ministry of Energy and Mines (MEM) appears to be doing a thorough job of documenting such liabilities in the mining sector, citing the alarming figure of 4,281 such liabilities classified as ‘high’ or ‘very high’ risk out of a total of 8,616 cases reviewed. Ancash is the region with the highest number of such liabilities.

However, little progress has been made so far in determining the appropriate remedial action and who should undertake it. No less than 7,531 of the environmental liabilities identified lack an agent responsible for remediation or even an environmental study to determine its likely scale.

On implementation, it is the Oficina de Evaluación y Fiscalización Ambiental (OEFA) in the Ministry of the Environment that is responsible for sanctioning enterprises who fail to take remedial actions, for example as set out in the Enviromental Impact Assessments (EIAs) of new projects.

The report specifically calls on Congress to repeal the measure taken in 2014 that halved the fines that the OEFA can impose. It also makes numerous appeals for more adequate staffing both at the OEFA and MEM’s Dirección General de Minas.

It shows that hydrocarbons are lagging badly, with the task of documentation beginning only in 2013. In this sector, it falls to OEFA to assume the identifying function; as of April 2015 it had visited only 33% of the oil wells identified by Petroperú in 2002.

On both fronts, the Ombudsman is vehement, pointing to the massive task ahead to determine the necessary remedial action and how to monitor its execution. Behind the measured tones in which it is couched, the report points to the huge potential threat to human well-being from failure to take prompt and proper action to deal with environmental liabilities.
http://www.defensoria.gob.pe/modules/Downloads/documentos/PPT-Informe-171-Pasivos-Ambientales.pdf