The new minister of energy and mines, Eleodoro Mayorga, announced on March 6 that the government ‘was going to eliminate the requirement for Environmental Impact Studies [EIAs] for seismic exploration’ for oil and gas.
A storm of protest has since erupted, including a strong letter signed by 35 NGOs and grassroots organisations, plus 25 individuals with a role in the sector, followed by a letter from Peru’s College of Biologists.
It has since become clear that Mayorga had jumped the gun: the minister of environment Manuel Pulgar-Vidal hastened to say that the matter was still ‘in process’ and they were discussing ‘technical issues’. He added that ‘no final decisions or agreement [between the two ministries] yet existed.’
Though we don’t yet know the extent of the weakening, there is every reason to be apprehensive. EIAs, as used to date in Peru, are far from ideal: in particular the consultation side can easily be made an empty process. But they represent an important line of defence for the environment.
Under the new proposals, an EIA could still be required in certain circumstances, but a Declaration would be used instead for seismic activity. Unlike an EIA, a Declaration would not require a valuation to be put on the environmental impact. Nor would it require citizen participation or the establishment of a base line to enable the estimation of social and environmental impacts. In other words, it would be much easier to accomplish. The Humala government has come under constant pressure from extractive industry lobby groups to reduce the burden of environmental or other regulation
EIAs were legislated over twenty years ago as the centrepiece of the system of regulation for extractive industries. They are necessarily time-consuming: they can take up to two years to complete and involve a serious research effort. But international rulings are increasingly identifying the EIA as key in a valid process of consulting with indigenous people. As of now there are 50 oil and gas projects at the exploration stage, 28 in the Amazon. As the protest letter from the NGOs says, EIAs need to be ‘strengthened not eliminated’.
Is this the right message for the country hosting the Climate Change conference in December of this year?
Recent Comments