This year’s annual conference addressed the themes of human rights and justice in Peru, marking the tenth anniversary of the final report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission on the internal conflict (1980-2000). Discussions benefited from the participation of Professor Jo-Marie Burt, who worked as a researcher for the TRC, experts on the justice system including Professor David Lovatón and Lord Brennan QC, a team working on a documentary on forced sterilisations in the 1990s, as well as campaigners from groups like Amnesty, journalists and members of the PSG.
We asked how far has Peru travelled since the TRC revealed that the conflict had killed 70,000 people, had involved the world’s highest level of forced disappearances in the world at the time and had led to sexual violence becoming at times systematic? To what extent have the TRC’s recommendations for truth, justice and reparation been achieved? Have the entrenched social divisions and discrimination that it documented been overcome?
Gap between policy and practice
While Peru’s legal framework has improved substantially since the end of the Fujimori regime, too often laws and policies are not translated into practice. This is also the case for international law, where adherence is seen to be declining. Of 26 rulings against the Peruvian government by the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, none has been complied with. International law on sexual violence is similarly not applied. There is a profound need for adequate resources and better training of frontline personnel. These could help to overcome barriers such as racist attitudes within the medical profession, which facilitated forced sterilisations, and inadequate support for women at under-resourced crisis centres.
‘De facto amnesty’ for human rights crimes
Nowhere is the gap more evident than in the extremely low rate of convictions for human rights crimes. Fujimori’s conviction in 2009 now appears as the high point in efforts to end impunity. Of cases coming from the TRC, only a quarter have secured conviction; many human rights cases are dismissed before they reach trial. In part this is due to sectors of the establishment closing ranks, particularly the Ministry of Defence refusing to release documents that could help to identify military perpetrators. The judiciary’s failure to take sexual violence seriously also plays a role. International pressure is needed to challenge this trend. Rulings by the Inter-American Court of Human Rights have some scope to empower actors within Peru. For more information on human rights trials, see Professor Burt’s http://rightsperu.net website.
Need for open dialogue for truth and reconciliation
The TRC’s report remains an important document and many Peruvians are keen to gain a better understanding of this period of their history in order to prevent a repeat. This can provide a basis for working towards broader social change. With the distance brought by time, participants discussed whether it might now be possible to establish more of a dialogue with the military, to create greater historical consensus. However, not only are parts of the Peruvian elite actively promoting a narrative of denial, but there is still a fear of being seen as being an ‘apologist for terrorism’. Another area of discussion was the need to preserve multiple voices – which can get lost in the requirement for somewhat standardised narratives in line with legal definitions of crimes. The growing concentration of media ownership is a threat to this.
International responsibility and solidarity
International actors need to recognise their share of responsibility. For example, USAID and the World Bank actively supported the sterilisation programme. Shouldn’t they contribute to reparations? Continuing international solidarity still has an important role to play in bolstering Peruvian civil society’s efforts for justice and human rights – and could become even more critical in the future, especially if Fujimori’s daughter Keiko is elected president in 2016.
Building support for human rights
Human rights lack strong support in Peru among popular sectors or a political champion. Public opinion is actually shifting in a negative direction: backing for Fujimori’s conviction and other key rulings has dropped significantly in recent years. Several speakers suggested that linking human rights to corruption – a far more widely understood problem – could be a way of generating more public commitment to human rights. Future campaigning should also give stronger emphasis to economic and social rights. After all, it was the exclusion of Peru’s indigenous communities that made them so vulnerable to human rights abuses throughout the conflict.
Recent Comments