The deal finally reached between the Bush administration and the Democratic leadership in the US Congress appears to have removed one of the main obstacles to US ratification of the Free Trade Agreement (FTA) between the United States and Peru. However, the devil may yet lie in the detail. The Democrats in Congress demand that there should be more effective guarantees included in the agreement with respect to labour rights and the environment.

The Peru Support Group has long argued that the proposed FTA between the United States and Peru, driven by powerful economic interests in Peru anxious to maintain access to the US market, threatens the livelihoods of countless Peruvians. Mostly poor and lacking in political influence, they will see their income undercut by cheap (often subsidised) imports from the United States. As in Mexico with the North America Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), farmers producing for the domestic market will be among those hardest hit.

Environmental and labour concerns
If environmental and labour safeguards can be made effective, they will go some way towards mitigating some of the more negative effects of the US-Peruvian FTA, although this will be of little consolation to many who are prejudiced by its economic impact. However, the problem lies in the fact that environmental and labour safeguards will probably mean relatively little on the ground.

On paper at least, Peru’s environmental code is quite advanced; the problem is that its provisions are often ignored, that they cannot be enforced, and that the effective penalties are not strong enough. The environmental problems afflicting the mining industry are symptomatic of this. Where upholding environmental standards costs money, and where investment seeks to hold down costs wherever possible, environmental safeguards are frequently sacrificed.

On the labour front, Peru is in the process of approving a new labour law. However, the new law does little to provide workers with the effective legal protection that they would enjoy in other countries. And even if it did, employers frequently find ways to dodge the provisions of employment law. Previous ‘flexibilisation’ of labour protection norms (to use the language of the World Bank) has already removed many of the rights once enjoyed (on paper at least) by Peruvian workers. In the hostile climate of the early 1990s, Peruvian trade unions found themselves powerless to resist labour market liberalisation.

Human Rights
Approval of the FTA should at least be made conditional on other provisos, notably Peru respecting human rights, both now and into the future. In its concern to build ties to the armed forces and the supporters of former president Alberto Fujimori, the García government has shown a worrying propensity to downplay a commitment to human rights, especially towards the work of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC).

In the interests of seeing the FTA approved by the US Congress, President García and his economic team will doubtless make the necessary undertakings on the environment and labour to appease the US critics of ratification. And if such changes to the original document require taking the amended agreement back to the Peruvian Congress, the latter will almost certainly oblige by passing whatever is required of it.

However, once the agreement is finally struck, it will prove very difficult for the US Congress – or anyone else for that matter – to hold the Peruvian authorities to honouring the commitments they have made on labour and environmental safeguards.