By Andrea Steel and Sophie Paton
A key area of concern first documented by the PSG last year in its ‘Mining and Poverty’ bulletin is the rise and escalation of mining-community conflicts. Mining is the country’s leading economic sector providing 55% of its exports and accounting for 6% of its GDP. However, although mining has the potential to contribute to Peru’s development and alleviate poverty, the rise of anti-mining protests and demonstrations has led to the delay and suspension of various mining and exploration projects around the country.
The main reason for these protests is largely the result of poor accountability and damaging social and environmental legacies that have undermined public trust in foreign and domestic mining companies in Peru. Issues of transparency, participation, consent and the distribution and perceived lack of mining benefits that local communities believe are due to them underpin many of these conflicts.
Hostile community relations can also lead to violence, as occurred at the Rio Blanco copper project in northern Peru, where demonstrations in April 2004 and July 2005 led to numerous arrests and the deaths of two protesters. Local communities are opposed to the development of the project by British junior exploration company Monterrico Metals because of environmental concerns and its community consultation practices. The PSG is currently in the process of investigating these claims.
The debate surrounding conflict and mining-community relations is one the industry must tackle as a whole. It is no longer viable for larger companies to distance themselves from the activities of juniors, but to assume responsibility for collective action towards sustainable development. While some important steps have been made, still no one can fail to notice the absence of discussion at trade and industry events of the rights and participation of NGOs and communities. Reducing such issues to a set of legal or voluntary requirements highlights an undercurrent of lack of trust and the need for further substantial disclosure about corporate plans of action.
The sensitivity of both companies and NGOs to public pressure is likely to increase as environmental issues surrounding climate change continue to dominate the headlines. British citizens will continue to demand and expect the highest possible standards of best practice for how UK businesses operate abroad. And companies that rely on existing social and environmental norms to guide their activities will face intensified local resistance unless they are shown to work in practice and open to independent verification. Striking a balance between responsible social, environmental and economic development can only be achieved in partnership with NGOs and communities. Companies that make strategic and operational decisions about the nature and impact of their activities in a host country will need to think about when and how they engage with NGOs and communities. NGOs will similarly have to reflect on the way they work, and how they sensitise their supporters and legitimately represent the interests of communities. Notwithstanding, it is vitally important to establish mechanisms for managing Peru’s wealth effectively to ensure the equitable distribution of the impacts and benefits of mining. Building effective community relations, providing accurate information and well-supported conflict resolution mechanisms to settle disputes in the mining sector is an essential first step.
For the full PSG report on mining in Peru go to :
www.perusupportgroup.org.uk/pdfs/psg_report_on_mining.pdf
This article appeared in Mining Environmental Management (July 2006) in a special edition of the magazine documenting the campaigns and challenges of NGOs on this issue. To see a copy of the magazine online, go to www.miningenvironmental.com and download the latest edition for free.
Recent Comments