Lessons from Brumadinho

03 February 2019

The catastrophic failure of the Vale tailings dam in Brazil, the second in three years, is a test for worldwide mining industry. Such tailing dams are some of the largest structures in the world with failure rates one hundred times greater than for water retention dams and the risks of failure are growing in time.

Such dams are meant to last for ever, so the initial design, the maintenance, the regulatory and inspection regimes are critical, even many decades after a mine has closed. If lessons are to be learned from Brumadinho, it is that regulation matters and that the regulators must not end up being ‘captured’ by those they seek to regulate.

In Peru the regulatory authority is OSINERGMIN which comes under the Ministry of Energy and Mines (MINEM) which is, in turn, the entity responsible for accelerating the development of mining.

The Vale dam that failed used the ‘upstream’ construction method which is known to be the least reliable of three tailing dam construction methods and is particularly suspect in earthquake zones. In Minas Gerais state legislature, there had been failed attempts to forbid this construction method. It should, however, be noted that Peru, Chile and others have for a long time banned the use of the ‘upstream’ method.

The UN and others have called for an impartial investigation into the collapse in Brazil, since it raises serious questions as to the stability of tailings dams elsewhere.

All news

  • PSG Aims

    The Peru Support Group exists to promote social inclusion, sustainable development and the observance of human rights in Peru. To that end the PSG highlights shortcomings in observance of established norms, whether international or local in nature, in its research, advocacy and publications. In so doing, it underscores the relationships that exist within the political system, how institutions work, and the effectiveness of policies that aim to reduce poverty and inequality within the context of sustainable development.

  • Historical Overview

    Over the past century Peru has suffered a series of autocratic governments and a civil war in which nearly 70,000 people died. Many of the country's ongoing political and social problems are a legacy of its somewhat turbulent past. 

  • Human Rights

    Human rights violations were widespread during the twenty years after the initiation of armed conflict in 1980. Efforts to convict perpetrators since the war's end have made only limited progress. Today, concerns remain over the treatment of those engaged in social protest, particularly against strategically important investment projects.

  • Why join the PSG?

    • Keep up to date with latest news and developments in Peru
    • Learn about key issues of poverty, development and human rights in Peru
    • Support the work of the Peru Support Group

    Become a member